Which is Best: Rowing Machine or Exercise Bike?

Which is Best: Rowing Machine or Exercise Bike? Rowing machines edge out as the best home cardio option in 2025, activating 86% of muscles for superior full-body strength and burning 600-800 calories per hour—15-20% more than bikes—while slashing joint strain by 70% versus high-impact activities, per expert comparisons.

Why Rowing Machines and Exercise Bikes Dominate Home Cardio

Both deliver low-impact endurance, cutting heart disease risk by 36% with regular use and boosting VO2 max by 10-15% in eight weeks. Rowing engages 86% of muscles for holistic toning; bikes target 50% (mainly legs) for leg power. Global cardio market surges to $9.46 billion by 2030 at a CAGR of 4.6%, with rowers at $1.41 billion in 2025 (CAGR 4.3%) and bikes at $1.80 billion for home models (CAGR 4.3%).

Core Benefits:

• Calorie Efficiency: Rowing torches 294-881 calories/hour; bikes 294-700, aiding 1-2 pounds weekly loss.
• Stress Reduction: 20% cortisol drop from rhythmic motion.
• Injury Prevention: Both minimize risks, but rowing’s full-body balance lowers overuse by 70%.

Explore cardio’s heart perks in Harvard Health’s exercise essentials.

Rowing Machine vs Exercise Bike: Head-to-Head Stats

Rowing wins for muscle recruitment and calorie density; bikes excel in sustained leg endurance and knee comfort for longer sessions. At moderate intensity, rowing burns 15-20% more due to upper-body involvement.

Rowing builds power-endurance; bikes enhance aerobic capacity but risk 10-15% knee issues without proper fit. “Rowing’s total engagement trumps biking for time-crunched gains,” says Garage Gym Reviews.

Types of Rowing Machines for Home Setup

Air rowers scale with effort for HIIT; water offers serene waves; magnetic ensures quiet precision. Air dominates 40% market for durability (15-20 years).

Types of Exercise Bikes for Varied Goals

Upright mimics road cycling; recumbent supports back for recovery; spin bikes add resistance for classes. Upright leads 60% market for versatility.

Top Models: Rowing Machines and Exercise Bikes in 2025

2025 picks from Garage Gym Reviews, Wirecutter, and BarBend prioritize value and tech.

Best Rowing: Concept2 RowErg

Concept2 RowErg ($900) air model tracks watts precisely, supporting 500 pounds. Folds compact; 4.6/5 for pro-level pulls.

Pros:

• Free app leaderboards
• 5-year warranty
• 86% muscle activation

Cons:

• 60dB fan
• No screen

Best Bike: Peloton Bike+

Peloton Bike+ ($2,495) upright with 100 levels and rotating 23.8-inch screen for 10,000+ classes. 297-pound capacity; 4.7/5.

Pros:

• Immersive metrics
• Auto-resistance
• $44/month library

Cons:

• Subscription-heavy
• 4-footprint

Value Rowing: NordicTrack RW900

NordicTrack RW900 ($1,299) magnetic with 26 levels and 22-inch iFit screen. Quiet; 4.5/5 for smooth glides.

Pros:

• <50dB operation
• Incline simulation
• $39/month iFit

Cons:

• Assembly 45 minutes

Value Bike: Schwinn IC4

Schwinn IC4 ($799) spin bike with 100 levels and Bluetooth for apps. 330 pounds; 4.6/5 for affordability.

Pros:

• Tablet holder
• Quiet belt drive
• Free workouts

Cons:

• Basic console

For full tests, view Wirecutter’s exercise bike roundup.

Key Factors for Choosing Rowing or Exercise Bike

Assess goals: Rowing for full-body (86% engagement); bikes for leg focus and longer rides. Space: Rowers 8×2 feet; bikes 4×2. Budget: $500-$1,000 entry; $1,500+ smart.

Selection Guide:

1. Strength/Full-Body: Rowing (higher burn).
2. Endurance/Legs: Bike (sustainable pacing).
3. Joint Health: Rowing reduces 70% strain.

Durability: 10-20 years for frames. “Pick by muscle needs—rowing for efficiency,” per Hydrow trainers.

FAQ

Which burns more calories: rowing or biking?

Rowing leads at 600-800/hour via 86% muscles; bikes 500-700, but match intensity for personalization.

Is rowing safer for joints than biking?

Yes—non-weight-bearing cuts knee risk by 70%; bikes suit but watch saddle height.

Space comparison?

Rowing: 8×2 feet, foldable; bikes: 4×2 feet, upright storage options.

Subscriptions needed?

Rowing (Concept2): Free; bikes (Peloton): $44/month for classes.

Weight loss edge?

Rowing—15-20% more burn sustains EPOC up to 14 hours; combine for 5-16% fat loss in four weeks.

Final Thoughts

Rowing machines top 2025’s cardio surge with versatile, joint-sparing power over bikes’ leg-centric focus. Align with priorities—full engagement for rowing, steady spins for bikes—for enduring routines. Master form at Garage Gym Reviews’ cardio tips.

About Author

Mariar Fernandez

Hi, I’m Mariar Fernandez, and I consider that every person can attain the frame in their goals. I’m a certified health and fitness trainer and have helped customers acquire their dream bodies for 15 years. Whether you’re looking to get beach body prepared, compete in a bodybuilding display, or really to enhance your confidence and well-being, I can help.

See author's posts